Bank lawsuits expose legal confusion over cybercrime0
Posted on 6th Jul 2011 by Gemalto in Corporate
In two consecutive weeks we saw headlines made by customer versus bank lawsuits relating to cybercrime.
In early June, a court in Maine ruled in favor of Ocean Bank in an ACH fraud lawsuit, saying that, “having verified IDs, passwords and requested challenge response questions, it acted in good faith by processing the ACH payments and Patco (the customer) was to blame for letting its details become compromised.” This week, however, we see a different (near opposite) ruling from a Texan judge which favored the business which had been the victim of fraud.
In the most recent case, the customer (Experi-Metal) was a victim of an apparent real-time phishing scam that resulted in almost 100 wire transfers (worth $560k) being processed after both their Comerica user credentials AND security token password were compromised. The judge stated: “A bank dealing fairly with its customer, under these circumstances, would have detected and/or stopped the fraudulent wire activity earlier.”
There are a few things worth noting in these scenarios, firstly the fact that neither of these banks are major financial institutions – meaning attackers are looking further afield for potential victims. By targeting smaller organizations, they obviously believe that they will be more likely to find the weak link in the security chain, wherever it is. This means that every institution, large or small, should have someone (or some group) that owns security for them and takes it seriously – before they end up in the news.
Secondly, no one wins from a lawsuit like this – there is no scenario where a bank should say “we won that one!” Whether a judge decrees it or not, it is the responsibility of the institution to provide a safe banking environment for customers, period.
Thirdly, the ruling shows that our current laws do not understand, or even agree on, what should be done. One judge ruled that questions and answers were good enough to protect the customer. Then, a separate judge rules that the bank should have detected a mere 100 wire transfers from an account after IDs, passwords, and its OTP token password were compromised.
I am no legal expert, but I feel the judge in Texas got it right, whilst his counterpart in Maine was probably basing his ruling on the fact that he has never had his credentials compromised.
Finally, it is important to note that protections that can thwart these attacks are both available and affordable. Online banking is now a critical piece of the delivery chain for banks of every size and, when a lawsuit like this happens, it calls attention to a growing problem. Coupled with recent attacks aimed at huge companies like Lockheed and Citibank, there is a real danger that customers may start to EXPECT to be compromised, and just avoid the channel entirely as a result. And that is the last thing that banks would want to happen.
Tags#GemaltoNFC 4G Apple BYOD Digital Security EMV Facebook Gemalto IOT IoTMaker Isis LTE M2M MasterCard Mobile NFC OTP Payments SIM SMS Twitter USA Visa authentication banking cio cloud contactless convenience ebanking fraud hacking identity innovation internet of things machine-to-machine mobile wallet mobile marketing mobile world congress mobile payments mobile payment multi-factor authentication online banking password passwords security smartphone strong authentication technology two factor authentication
Around the siteRecent Posts
- MWC After Dark: Where to go when the hard work is over - 27/02/15 @ 03:25
- MWC 2015: Speeding up urgent communication with M2M - 27/02/15 @ 10:29
- MWC 2015: Making life faster for brands and consumers alike - 26/02/15 @ 02:56
- Who to follow at Mobile World Congress 2015 - 26/02/15 @ 11:47
- Six things to pack in your MWC survival bag - 25/02/15 @ 02:21
- The resource that you mentioned here is something t... - 22/01/15 @ 09:42
- very interesting ; was just trying to get in touch ... - 16/01/15 @ 05:22
- Security will no doubt be at stake with connected c... - 08/01/15 @ 02:29
- Informative post. Thanks. - 07/01/15 @ 09:56
- It’s true I didn’t really call out HCE by name in m... - 06/01/15 @ 03:54
- Gemalto (199)
- Tim Cawsey (57)
- Marta Bordonada (52)
- Dominique Brulé (37)
- Jennifer Dean (33)
- Manfred Kube (31)
- Bernd Eckenfels (28)
- Philippe Benitez (28)
- Kristel Teyras (23)
- Ken Abbott (20)
- John Ahlberg (19)
- Neville Pattinson (15)
- Nicole Williams (13)
- Isabelle Lodo (12)
- Jack Jania (11)
- Brittany Jedrzejewski (11)
- Rémi de Fouchier (10)
- Michelle Leech (10)
- Axel Hansmann (10)
- Stéphanie Viriot (9)
- Cecile Eurendjian (8)
- Kim Depussé (8)
- Paul Kobos (8)
- Ernesto Haikewitsch (7)
- Naomi Lurie (7)
- Arta Sylejmani (6)
- Pierre Lelievre (6)
- Shannon Taylor (5)
- Frederic Martinez (5)
- Vincent Truffier-Blanc (5)